Our Menu
Daily Specials
Monday
$14.99
Funky Chicken Salad
Tuesday
$12.95
Chicken Caesar Wrap with Sweet Potato or Regular Fries
Wednesday
$1.00
$1 Wings
Thursday
$12.99
BLT - Served with Fries or Sweet Potato Fries
Friday
$14.99
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Saturday
$5 off any 18" Speciality Pizza
Sunday
$30.00
2 Topping 14" pizza w/ 6 Wings
Appetizers
The Rusty Onion
$10.49
Sautéed caramelized onions served with our zesty Italian cream dip and flatbread chips
Boneless Tenders
$14.49
5 Hand-breaded tenders, tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with celery and carrots. Choice of ranch or blue cheese. Sauces: Mild, Buffalo, BBQ, Bee Sting, Italian, 911, Barbalo, Honey Hot, Honey BBQ, Lemon Pepper, Jamaican Jerk
Tuscany Bread
$10.49
Sliced ciabatta loaf, basil pesto, fresh spinach, & mozzarella cheese topped with our homemade bruschetta mix and balsamic glaze
Fried Pickle Sticks
$10.49
Served with ranch or blue cheese and aioli
Knotted Up
$4.99/+
Light, fluffy garlic knots with fresh herbs, parmesan cheese, & marinara | 6pc • $4.99 / 12pc • $7.99
Knotted up Sliders
$8.99
4 delicious garlic knots with seasoned meatball, mozzarella cheese & marinara stuffing
Squeaky Cheese
$8.99
Delicious fried cheese curds served with a side of marinara
Mozz Logs
$11.49
4 Large Mozzarella Logs served with a side of marinara
Cheese & Bacon Fries
$10.49
Hand-cut fries smothered with melted cheddar cheese sauce & bacon crumbles. Served with ranch or blue cheese
Garlic Cheesy Bread
$6.99
Our classic handmade dough topped with mozzarella, fresh garlic & herb parmesan
Queen City Wings
$11.49/+
Jumbo-sized wings fried & tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with celery & carrots. Choice of ranch or blue cheese. Sauces: Mild, Buffalo, BBQ, Bee Sting, Italian, 911, Barbalo, Honey Hot, Honey BBQ, Lemon Pepper, Jamaican Jerk | 6pc • $11.49 / 12pc • $17.49 / 24pc • $30.99
Salads
Add Grilled, Blackened, or Fried Chicken Breast to any salad for $5.99 | Dressings: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Blue cheese, Caesar, Ranch, 1000 Island, Honey Mustard, Yia Yia Margaret's Famous Greek Dressing
House Salad
$5.99/+
Romaine, red onions, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers & croutons | Small: $5.99 / Entrée: $10.99
Popeye
$9.99/+
Fresh baby spinach, blue cheese crumbles, mushrooms, candied walnuts, red onions, bacon | Small: $9.99 / Entrée: $14.99
Greek Salad
$9.99/+
Romaine, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, sun-dried cranberries & crumbled feta cheese. Served with our Yia Yia Margaret's Famous Greek Vinaigrette | Small: $9.99 / Entrée: $14.99
Dear Brutus
$6.99/+
Romaine topped with croutons, shaved parmesan, and served with Caesar dressing | Small: $6.99 / Entrée: $14.49
Funky Chicken
$16.99
Your choice of grilled, blackened, or fried chicken breast served over romaine lettuce, sun-dried tomatoes, cucumber, and pepperoncini, with cheddar jack cheese
Buffalo Chicken Salad
$16.99
(Fried or Grilled) Buffalo chicken breast on top of romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, bacon, & blue cheese crumbles. Served with blue cheese dressing
Sandwiches / Spinach Wraps
Served with a choice of hand-cut regular or sweet potato fries | Substitutions (+$2.50): Side House or Caesar salad, Mac n' Cheese, Onion Rings, or Broccoli
Sandwich of Brotherly Love
$16.99
Hand-shaved Philly beef or chicken topped with sautéed mushrooms, onions, green peppers, provolone cheese, and roasted red pepper mayonnaise on a hoagie. - Or try the "Philly Philly" way with cheese sauce
One Clucking Good Sandwich
$14.99
Grilled marinated chicken breast, with roasted red peppers, red onions, smoked provolone, lettuce, and basil pesto sauce. Served on a toasted bun
BBQ Bacon Chicken Sandwich
$14.99
(Fried or Grilled) Chicken breast drizzled in BBQ sauce & served with cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce & tomato on a bun
Meatball Classic
$13.99
Traditional style meatball sandwich served with melted mozzarella cheese, and covered in our marinara sauce
Gyro Pita Sandwich
$13.49
Sliced Gyro meat with lettuce, tomato, & onion. Topped with Yia Yia's famous tzatziki sauce
Chicken Pita Sandwich
$13.99
Sliced Chicken Breast with lettuce, tomato, & onion. Topped with Yia Yia's famous tzatziki sauce
BLT Sandwich
$12.99
Traditional BLT on brioche bread with mayo, Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
$14.99
(Fried or Grilled) Chicken breast dipped in our mild or buffalo sauce and topped with blue cheese crumbles, lettuce, and tomato on a bun
Eye - Talian
$15.99
Fresh Italian cold cuts, cappicola, prosciutto, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and balsamic vinaigrette served hot on a hoagie
Hippie Burger
$13.99
A black bean patty topped with spicy aioli, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion
California Chicken Sandwich
$14.99
Marinated chicken breast, with bacon, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, & onion. Served on a bun with an avocado spread
The Rusty Onion Burger*
$16.99
1/2 lb Angus beef grilled & topped with grilled onions, mushrooms, bacon, swiss cheese, & red pepper mayonnaise. Served on a bun
The Opa Burger*
$16.99
1/2 lb Angus beef grilled & topped with Feta cheese, lettuce, tomato, caramelized onion, & tzatziki sauce. Served on a bun
Build Your Own Burger
$16.99
Choose up to five toppings! Served on a bun
Entrees
All entrées served with choice of side salad (House or Caesar) & table bread
Meatball Ravioli
$18.49
Meatballs served with our traditional marinara sauce over cheese ravioli & topped with parmesan cheese
Chicken Parmesan
$18.99
Breaded & Fried chicken breast on top of angel hair pasta, topped with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
Eggplant Parmesan
$16.49
Lightly fried fresh eggplant served with spaghetti, sautéed mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella & marinara sauce
Chicken Penne
$18.99
Blackened chicken breast, sautéed green peppers & onions, tossed in a gorgonzola cream sauce
Cheese Manicotti
$15.99
Three hand-rolled manicotti tubes filled with creamy ricotta cheese, topped with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
Smothered Chicken
$17.49
Marinated chicken breast with bacon, sautéed mushrooms, onions & melted provolone cheese on top of angel hair pasta
Homemade Lasagna
$18.99
Delicious meat lasagna with layers of pasta, Angus ground beef, ricotta and romano cheeses, marinara, and topped with melted mozzarella
Specialty Pizzas
Make any 10" Specialty Pizza Gluten Free: +$3.00
Hot Carnivore
$18.00/+
Red sauce base with meatballs, Italian sausage & pepperoni under a juicy layer of melted mozzarella, and crispy, crunchy bacon bits | 10" • $18.00 / 14" • $22.00 / 18" • $28.00
Supreme Pizza
$17.00/+
Red sauce base with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, white onions, & mozzarella | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Bianca
$17.00/+
Classic white pie with our garlic/EVOO sauce, ricotta, tomato slices, fresh spinach, & mozzarella cheese | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Mac N Cheese Pizza
$17.00/+
Noodles tossed in a Béchamel crème cheese sauce, topped with cheddar & mozzarella cheese | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
BBQ Chicken
$17.00/+
BBQ sauce base with chicken, cheddar cheese, red onions, cilantro, and mozzarella | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Buffalo Chicken
$17.00/+
Mild buffalo sauce base with goat cheese spread, grilled chicken, blue cheese crumbles, red onions, cheddar cheese, & mozzarella | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Shroomin' Fun Guy
$17.00/+
Our garlic/EVOO sauce with mushrooms, onions, goat cheese, & roasted garlic spread, topped with mozzarella, arugula, & white truffle oil | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Eye-Talian Stallion
$17.00/+
White sauce base with prosciutto, salami, bacon, black olives, artichokes, minced garlic, and mozzarella cheese | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Greek Pizza
$17.00/+
Our garlic/EVOO sauce with sliced tomatoes, red onions, kalamata olives, banana peppers, mozzarella, & crumbled feta cheese | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Cheese Steak D-Light
$17.00/+
Roasted red pepper base with hand-ground in-house Philly beef, caramelized onions, & mushrooms, topped with cheddar & mozzarella cheese | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Great Balls of Fire
$17.00/+
Red sauce base with our delicious meatballs, red onions, tomato slices, roasted red peppers, & mozzarella cheese | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Presto Pesto
$17.00/+
Pesto base with fresh spinach, tomato slices, mushrooms, & mozzarella cheese | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Ooh Yeah
$17.00/+
Red sauce base with fresh spinach, artichokes, pineapple, and jalapenos | 10" • $17.00 / 14" • $21.00 / 18" • $25.50
Build Your Own Pizzas
Choose your size, base sauce, and cheese, then add toppings to complete your masterpiece | 10" Gluten Free • $15 / 10" • $13.95 / 14" • $16.95 / 18" • $19.95 | All Toppings: 10" • $2.00 each / 14" • $2.75 each / 18" • $3.00 each
Sauces
Red/Tomato, Green/Pesto, BBQ Sauce, White/Garlic & EVOO (Extra Virgin Olive Oil)
Cheeses
Cheddar, Feta, Mozzarella, Ricotta, Shaved Parmesan
Meats
Bacon, Cappicola, Ground Beef, Sausage, Pepperoni, Prosciutto, Salami, Chicken, Meatballs, Ham
Veggies
Artichoke, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Broccoli, Roasted Red Peppers, Green Olives, Green Peppers, Jalapeños, Red/White Onions, Pepperoncini, Spinach, Fresh Basil, Caramelized Onions, Kalamata Olives, Pineapple, Sliced Tomatoes, Sun Dried Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Minced Garlic
Calzones & Strombolis
Four Cheese Calzone
$12.49
Romano, Mozzarella, Parmesan, and Ricotta Cheeses
Meat Lovers Stromboli
$15.99
No Substitutions | Pepperoni, Sausage, Meatballs, Bacon, and Mozzarella Cheese
Sausage Calzone
$14.99
No Substitutions | Our four cheese calzone with Sausage, green pepper, and caramelized onions
Build Your Own Calzone -Or- Stromboli
$12.49
Choose any of the toppings above at $1.00 per topping
Little Sprouts (Kids Menu)
Ages 12 & under only. All kids' meals served with a tea or soft drink
Rusty's Ravioli
$8.49
Cheese Ravioli with tomato sauce & 2 meatballs
Kids Pasta
$7.49
Served with Marinara or Butter
Flatbread Pizza
$7.49
Choice of Cheese or Pepperoni
Grilled Cheese
$7.49
Served with hand-cut regular or sweet potato fries
Chicken Tenders
$8.99
3 hand-breaded chicken tenders, served with hand-cut or sweet potato fries
Sides
Rusty Onion Rings
$5.99
Homemade onion rings served with our house-made chipotle aioli
Hand-Cut Fries Or Sweet Potato Fries
$5.99
Classic crispy greatness you'd expect with a great meal
Mac N' Cheese
$6.49
Béchamel crème cheese sauce & noodles topped with cheddar
Steamed Broccoli
$5.49
Tasty little trees
Meatballs
$2.25/Each
The best part of any pasta
Extra Side of Dressing Or sauce
$0.50
Add a little extra housemade flavor
Desserts
Cannoli
$6.50
Hand-rolled shell, piped with chocolate chip pastry cream
Cheesecake
$7.50
The famous "Mother's Cheesecake" from New Jersey
Chocolate Spoon Cake
$7.50
A perfect amount of chocolate pudding layered in-between a tasty chocolate cake (with our without a scoop of vanilla ice cream)
Homemade Chocolate Chip Cookie
$6.99
2 warm homemade chocolate chip cookies topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream
Fried Oreos
$6.50
6 perfect little chocolate sandwich cookies fried to golden perfection